I have spent a lot of time lately thinking about the ideal career trajectory for a football player in the NFL. I'm not even sure WHY I've been thinking about this other than it's a topic I find mildly fascinating. (Generally speaking, I'm not even an NFL fan.)
This is how the conversation with myself goes when I drive to work in the morning:
These dudes start out in high school as stars, go to college and get beat around on the field there for a couple of years. In return for the development and exposure on the national stage they also get a free education, if they happen to be on scholoarship. But, they're not allowed to have other jobs. Their job is football and school, per the NCAA. Collectively, they bring their schools and the NCAA millions (perhaps billions?) of dollars in revenue from ticket sales, licensed merchandise, other things I'm not even aware of and alumni donations. (Because when the football team is doing well, people tend to have warmer and fuzzier feelings about the school and they write checks more easily.)
In return, they get the crap beat out of them and they have a good time and they hope to maybe get drafted one day. If they don't, they hope the education they got nets a decent job. They also hope that they do not suffer a career-ending injury before their career even starts.
This seems like a crap deal for the player. Actually, it's OBVIOUSLY a crap deal for the player. The player seems to be taking on a lot of risk for not a lot of reward at this point. (It's only potential reward, and it's a slim opportunity at best.) The value of the scholarship can't possibly equal the value the player brings to the school. It's a closed system though, so if a guy wants to play in the NFL he NEEDS that game time at a Division 1 school and, well, those are the terms it's offered under. Take it or leave it. There's not really another path to professional success. I'm not saying I know what the GOOD deal or path is, but it just seems kind of lopsided and crappy to me. (And, obvs I am only talking about mid to top tier players at Division 1 schools here. People who have no chance to make it to the NFL don't fit into my daily oddball thoughts on this subject.)
If you don't get drafted maybe that's okay. Maybe, for some people, the opportunity for an education was worth it and the physical toll in college wasn't too great and, besides that, it was fun. (Even though I hate the idea of "fun" as valid compensation. You can't eat fun. You can't retire on fun. Fun is percieved and valued relative to the individual. I am sure there are people who hate playing football but do it anyway for other reasons.)
If the dude actually gets drafted it's a different story. He finally makes some money off of his talent that other people have been making money off of for years. He plays in the NFL and he gets paid pretty well. Maybe even REALLY well. His career can end at any time, on or off the field, with one car accident or one bad hit or one blown knee.
But, the risk a player takes on is not why he gets paid a lot. They get paid a lot because there's a lot of money to go around in this business. I don't think there are any owners paying players a lot of money because they know this money is supposed to last the next 70 years for the player. They pay them a lot so they won't play on other teams that will pay them more. But, only a few players get that kind crazy-money treatment. I mean, the league minimum is $310k. If a person played for three years at that rate (I know it would go up a little each year, but let's keep the math simple), after taxes it'd be about $600k. Hardly "last a lifetime" money.
Plus, these guys are on the clock. For a "career" it sure doesn't last a long time. The player's association backs this up: average tenure in the NFL is 3.5 seasons and 24% of the players get injured every year. That's...a lot of hurt dudes. Even if someone doesn't get dinged in that 24%? Most guys will get injured, either spectacularly or slowly, over the spread of a few seasons. Their usefulness will wane. But, some will still keep playing as long as someone pays.
The Smart Dudes see this coming and they save their money, play wisely and well for a few years and stop. They will stop before the damage to their bodies becomes noticeable at the ripe old age of 25. They will stop playing and they will take that money and do something else with it like start a business or get a job coaching or SOMETHING, ANYTHING. Basically, they stop getting the shit beat out of them.
The Stupid Dudes keep playing, keep slogging through, keep coming back. When a team releases him he finds a new one. When he gets injured he rehabs it and goes back. He plays for what is considered a long time: 5 or 8 years. Maybe more. By the time he's finished, either by choice or forced circumstance, he's done a lot of damage to his body. He'll be old before he's middle-aged. He'll hurt for a long time. But he might have a nice stash of cash for his trouble. (But! Money! It does not buy happiness!) If he's lucky, he was a good, notable player and maybe he has some endorsements. But if he didn't save his money and he was an average player with no star power, he's under 30 and he probably needs a job.
And none of this is news, really. It's all been said and pointed out by people far more sports-minded than I am. (But, like I said, I CAN'T HELP THINKING ABOUT THIS FOR SOME ODDBALL REASON.)
In this sense, being a professional football player doesn't sound awesome to me. It sounds like a lot of sacrifice and risk for a slim chance at great reward. It sounds a lot like using your 401k to buy lottery tickets. I don't see this level of risk taken on in other professional sports, which is why I think I find it all so mind-boggling and interesting that anyone would WANT to do this with their life. Perhaps I'm totally wrong though?
It's just...I don't know. I don't think I'm that far off. Why do kids want to do this? (Likely Answers: Fame. Fortune. Chicks.) It doesn't seem all that wonderful when the realities are examined and the alternatives considered. Even when it works out and you're a star and you make millions it seems like your body will be broken before you're 50 if you spend a significant amount of time in the NFL. And even if you get lucky and don't end up all broken and bruised, there's all of that RISK the entire time you're on the field. Your quality of life after the game is almost guaranteed to be kind of crappy in a physical well-being sense. Aren't there other ways to make your fortune and keep your knees?
(Maybe yes, but those ways require more effort and time unless you invent Facebook so, hell yes, they'll totally go knock some dudes down and get paid and worry about the future later. Knees? In ten years they'll be able to grow new knees from cucumbers in the KneeMaker4000. KNEES ARE OPTIONAL.)
(Also, I know that for some talented kids football seems like A Way Out or a Ticket To A Good Future and I get that but I just figure almost anyone is better off taking the education and running the other way than going for the draft.)
It seems so selfish. Who wants to not be able to run around with your kids at 45? Who wants to live a life in constant pain? Who wants to have joints that ache when your wife is still walking with ease at 40? I know the obvious answer is that this seems EASY and if there's anything people like it's easy money, but man...it doesn't seem all that easy to me. (Gah, this is SUCH a Mom sentiment isn't it? "Don't get hurt! Get a desk job!")
There must be players that don't fit into this description. Players that are healthy and feel good after their days on the field are over. Players that saved their money. But, I am guessing they are the exception.
It's like a question in one of those books: If you could be guaranteed several million dollars, fame and the best time of your life for three years, but afterwards would likely be in a great deal of physical pain for the rest of your life, with an added risk of brain damage, would you do it?
Uh, no. No, I would not.
***
(I promise that you will never see another sports post on this website again. I've got it out of my system now.)